Usually the 3 inch pulley goes bad and the 3.5 is ok. After replacing the 3 inch one 3 times, I changed both of mine to the 3.5 and haven't had to change them since. It's a tight fit, but makes the belt a bit tighter too so it doesn't slip on the supercharger. I get mine from Rockauto if you can wait, or any of the parts stores if you need it then. I've had better luck with the metal pulleys than the plastic ones.