The plug wires are for sure correct. Triple checked them. All the connectors are plugged in. All the ignition fuses are good. The grounds all appear to be connected. I never touched the starter wires when I pulled my motor, I just unbolted it from the block. The battery is reading 12.78 volts without the key in the ignition. I haven't checked for spark yet, as I'm the only one home and I don't have anyone to crank the engine for me.
I did notice something though... The clip holding the camshaft position sensor broke off, but I can't tell if the connector is still pushed in all the way. The grey rubber grommet around it is sticking out a bit, is that normal? Here's a picture:
