I'd pick the Milwaukee because pegboard spot, even though black is better than red. Seriously, tool storage hype eludes me entirely. 15 years of car fixin job so far on one $180 (new) Craftsman here. A cardboard box will hold tools as well as a shelf or the floor, and neither of the boxes shown are much of a status symbol. A second-hand box with a new paint job could be a great score and project with lasting rewards.