You'll see a lot of haters when you mention the alt re-wire and any fuel mileage increases. But Ive done similar re-wires on three vehicles now and I am VERY anal about tracking my fuel economy. Im like you in that I save my receipts, the tank is topped off until it cant take no more and I write down the trip odometer and main odometer at each tank and reset the trip odometer at each tank and then I manually calculate the mileage and I keep a log.
Its only three vehicles so far, but I have yet to see one that did not benefit from using better or larger wiring than the OEM set up.