I dunno, I guess if I spent more on Oil analysis than an engine or transmission is worth, then I suppose. When I can SAFELY run 15, 20, 30k miles on an oil change with no degradation to the engine I think you would be hard pressed to reach a point of overkill. I ran 15k on one oil change with a LIM leak. The engine never showed any significant increase in wear.Originally Posted by IndeedSS
I was kidding. However, isn't there a point of overkill or going beyond the added benfits, for the application in use? Not saying this is the case, because, I have no idea. Just a devils advocate POV.
Additionally, the oil analysis gives me much more advanced warning of any impending trouble such as coolant leaks LONG before they leave me stranded somewhere.
So from my personal viewpoint and several years of experience using oil analysis, I dont think you could reach a point of overkill anytime soon. Yes, the additional cost is there initially until you establish how far you can go and what the engine is doing. After that point, the cost of maintenance drops significantly.
I sponsor a local drag bike racer who runs in the super gas class, indexes at 9.90 and is trapping around 135 - 140 mph. Its a dedicated drag bike and all it does is go down the track. I took him from spending money for an oil change and filter after every race to just one oil change and one filter in the race season and on top of that reduced his wear numbers significantly.
He runs I believe 8 races a year PLUS his test and tune sessions PLUS his practice sessions. The first season I sponsored him, yes it was an additional cost because we did not know where the numbers would fall. So we were running an analysis after every other race I believe. But we now have him on once a season oil analysis and once a season oil changes. Runs in the neighborhood of $60 for everything compared to around $15 x 8 = $120 and that is conservative because he was using manufacturer filters. So I think a 50% cost savings is pretty significant. And that is just for one bike on his team.
I have pictures (not digital unfortunately) from when he opened up the engine last season (after three years of me sponsoring him) and there was virtually no visible signs of wear in the valve train. When I started sponsoring him he had just rebuilt the engine and was telling me that it was nearly almost a given that you would have to rebuild some part of the engine every season. So factor that into the cost savings as well. He is now getting ready to start his 4th season on that same motor.
We could also add that information is power. Which is better, going down the track and loosing a motor because there was something going wrong internally and was unaware or knowing well in advance and being able to take corrective action prior to race day?
There are just a TON of advantages to using oil analysis. The cost savings is HUGE in the big picture. Just one other quick example. I have a customer that has a commercial floor cleaning business. Its a Dodge 3500 5.9L Turbo diesel. Holds 12 quarts of oil. He was having to change the oil about every 3 - 4 weeks because of the miles he drove. That cost him $40 - 50 depending on where he had it done PER oil change.
He contacts me, we talk. Put him on synthetics, run oil analysis a few times to figure out where he would have to set his maintenance schedule at. He went from oil changes every 5k miles (which as stated he was doing in about a months time) to oil changes once a year or around 60k miles. The oil and the filter ran him around $120 I believe it was because he went with the super high end oil. 40 x 12 = $480 vs $120. Throw in the cost of the oil analysis and I still had him under $250. His wear numbers dropped (less engine wear) and he was getting better fuel economy (less fuel expense). Now he changes the oil and filter once a year, runs an oil analysis to make sure everything is holding up and continues on.
Oh, also, he was using about a quart to a quart and a half of oil between oil changes prior to speaking with me. That has stopped to. He last reported he had to top off with maybe two quarts over the course of a year. Not bad in my opinion.
And I have many such examples such as those I mentioned.
