Granted, this was for a 97-03, but I got an aftermarket bumper cover from Carpartswholesale, for $50 shipped. It was brand new, and it fit perfectly. It had a gel coat finish, so it had to be sanded, and a few of the edges needed to have them trimmed with a razorblade to get rid of the molding excess. Total prep time was around 1 hour before I started spraying primer.
Your best bet is to find a color matched in a junkyard. The 2nd best would to get a new aftermarket one, and have it professionally painted to match the car.
