Quote Originally Posted by Reptile View Post
This just supports what I've said for years that Dex is not a bad product. The problem is the crap that people put in their coolant systems to fix leaks, and not maintaining the system. If you take care of things, it will survive. Don't patch a problem...FIX IT.
does not GM put those seal tabs in the cooling system from the factory?

I also dont think its all the stuff people put in their cooling systems as, generally speaking, people are pretty neglectful of their cooling systems. Im sure adding something to fix a leak doesnt help, I agree with you there as there is virtually no way to know if there will be a chemistry conflict in the composition of the products, but I dont think its a leading cause.

Dex Cool itself may not be a 'bad' product so much as it is a bad combo. A high maintenance product (Despite its label) coupled with one system in a car that gets very little attention by most owners.

One of the major things seems to be Dex-Cools sensitivity to air. And then the mentioning of contaminants in a virtually closed system. I would like to know how, in a virtually closed system, I would be responsible for contaminants. Ive pulled radiator caps off extremely low mileage vehicles (we're talking less than a year old) and there had been dex sludge in quite abundance on them.

Im not picking Reptile, just kinda contesting what you are saying because I see things a bit differently. You certainly have an inside track on things. But the information I have read over the years certainly doesnt say that DexCool is a 'bad' product but it is far from being as good or equivalent to anything else out there.