Yeah, I think I'll end up repainting the front bumper... hopefully with some decently matched paint.
According to the VIN, my car is a GT, and not an SE in GT badges, but at some point someone probably replaced parts for some reason.
Oh well, I can live with it for now, until I decide to hit up the wreckers and see if I can find a good quality replacement... or maybe I'll switch it up and replace all the interior with 04+ seats like in the write-up on the site
Thanks for all your help and suggestions everyone.
Cheers,
Chris