It has gotten a LOT better in the last two weeks or so. I may modify the re-direct some to account for, as you say, some people making mistakes.
I see many from new members, which to an extent, I understand. However, it would not hurt to take the time to look over the descriptions and ask yourself does this post belong here?
I will probably amend it to state something along the lines that if you have fewer than say 5 posts, maybe 10 posts, then I will leave a redirect. After that you are on your own and will have to find your post.
What strikes me in this, since stopping the redirects, Ive had no one contact me and ask me where their post was, which indicates to me they kinda know it was in the wrong place and they found it by looking where it should have been to start with.
We'll see. If the trend continues I'll amend it with the post limit for the redirects. If I could set it up where you could get infractions (for the people that have been here a while) for misplaced posts but not incur the points where you would get banned, then I would do that as well and then after so many infractions your posts start to get deleted.
As I said, Im not trying to be a jerk, but it got absolutely insane there for a while moving all the posts and while I dont mind helping out with that from time to time, there comes a point when you got to be held accountable for your actions. Its not like its a lot of work and if its a matter of the descriptions not being clear enough to know, then thats on me but I would need the members of the community to let me know so that issue can be addressed.