Actually your best bet is a Supra (You didn't say money was a factor, Just late 90's and boosted lol)
If money is a factor I'd say your best bet if the car you want has to be boosted would be a Eagle Talon/ Mitsu Eclipse with the 4g63 Motor. Find one with a 6 bolt motor swap tho unless you enjoy crank walk. They can be made decently fast for cheap. Just don't be a douche and act like its the fastest thing in the world.