mechanical is always more accurate than electric gauge.
That's way too vague. It depends on who makes it. The factory MAP sensor is very accurate, and I'd be inclined to believe it over any aftermarket gauges.
2004 Impala LS - got some mods sold!!!
2009 Subaru Impreza WRX STI
NAIOA moderator Still Imp'n, just in a different Imp.