i love the rollers because it quited down my valve train. it also picks up better rpms down low when people say you dont really notice the rockers till high rpm. i can tell the difference all around. its got a smother pull all threw the powerband.
true i cant compare a 1.8 stock to a 1.8 roller but in generally the rollers are a lot nicer. the excess lift is nice at high rpm but that is true with all rockers.
the fact can be argued which one is better. i have rollers and i love them, even if they were stock lift. to me its worth the little bit of extra money to op for them IMO.