When people here are talking about "too much KR" are they talking about a perceivable loss in power/predetonation e.g. knocking or are they talking about KR done, transparent to the driver, by the ECM and knock sensor?
|
|
08-09-2010
When people here are talking about "too much KR" are they talking about a perceivable loss in power/predetonation e.g. knocking or are they talking about KR done, transparent to the driver, by the ECM and knock sensor?
08-09-2010
second sticky from the top. posted by reptile. lots of good stuff there
08-09-2010
That's not really what I'm talking about.
The ECM can retard the timing of the engine to prevent detonation. When people here talk about a smaller pulley causing too much KR, it seems to me that this could be referring to two different things:
1) The additional boost by a smaller pulley is causing perceptable knocking and hestiation as detonation occurs.
2) The additional boost by a smaller pulley is forcing KR by the ECM without the knowledge of the driver
Let me put this another way: I have a '98GTP with a smaller pulley. I have done no performance modifications other than basic ignition (new coil packs and new wires). I have NEVER once had anything I would call a knock, I've never thrown a code, and I've never had anything that I would describe as perceivable KR.
My question: could I still be having "too much KR" as a result of the pulley swap but not know it because my ECM is doing the work for me?
I've had the new pulley for at least a year and my car has never ran better (or faster). What's more: I run crap gas (85 octane at 5500ft elevation) without any problem whatsoever.
Or - let me put it another way: do you need a scanner to know if you're getting too much KR?
08-09-2010
let me help you here.
YOUR MOTOR IS KNOCKING!!!!, if you are running 85 pump gas and have a smaller pulley that so called motor that in under your hood there, is gunna blow the ****!!!! up.
you need to run 91 or higher gas in the GTP's, that 85 sh!t is horrible for these cars, And you need flow mods STAT my friend.
I dont know alot about the knock and KR stuff yet, but I know that flow mods and the right gas and other shuff will help the motor out.
Last edited by Fivefingerdeathpunch; 08-09-2010 at 06:03 PM.
08-09-2010
you are getting detonation. the ecm won't prevent it from happening, but rather, it tries to. it "hears" detonation, then pulls timing to prevent more detonation, then slowly adds more timing back in. you really need to scan for KR.
08-09-2010
when KR is present, the car has already detonated. KR is a reaction to the problem, not the other way around.
the more boost you run (smaller pulleys) the less KR you want to see. even low amounts of detonation on a lot of boost can destroy things.
08-09-2010
Some people just say knock when referring to KR (knock retard). You can't physically hear KR, but you can hear knock. Knocking is a mechanical problem that is most likely a bad rod bearing or main bearing, or something else actually hitting another part. KR blows and it is noticeable if you have enough, especially if you know what it's like running KR free. How small of an s/c pulley do you have on?
08-09-2010
you can hear detonation if its bad enough.
08-09-2010
You wont hearing the typical pinging because these cars pull timing the instant it detects it.
But for real, your engine is being pushed WAY too hard for the amount its flowing.
08-09-2010
Keep in mind - the altitude here means that the octane available is not as high. The three grades are 85, 87 and 91.
I know a tremendous amount about octane - hell I even had several classes on it in college (Thermo 1, 2 and heat transfer).
What I don't know is how the GTP handles knock; or, more specifically, how perceptable it is without a scanner.
As I said, I've never had any issues with hesitation, pinging, or anything performance related. With my altitude, I get 20% less O2, so it's possible that whatever KR problems the rest of the country has is just not noticeable here.
I used to run nothing but 91 octane since I bought the car new way back when. When I bought my new GTO, I was hemmorhaging $ for gas, and decided to get gas on the cheap for my GTP. Ever since then even with the new pulley (3.2 if memory serves me correct), I've been running the cheapest thing possible without any performance issues whatsoever (same mileage, same performance, no issues at all). I have put about 20k miles on it since my pulley swap.
So, it's certainly possible I'm seeing KR, but the question I must ask is "should I care"?
08-09-2010
LOL at "should I care"
If you're tight for gas money then yes.
If you dont give a **** if you destroy your engine then no.
Thats the short and simple version.
Get a scan gauge already and be on what we call "the safe side".
08-09-2010
if it was a 3.2 your motor would be toast, its prolly a 3.4 or 3.5, but still smaller pulley with out proper mods is bad.
08-09-2010
08-09-2010
/\ is what will happen to you said motor.
08-09-2010
dude give me your gto, you dont deserve it
08-09-2010
The pcm does only so much to counter-act knock, thats why it's called knock-RETARD. A stock car will have knock from factory at times. By running more boost without decent flow mods and low octane, your increasing the chances of having uncontrollable amounts of knock. These 3800's are a pretty damn good block (870+whp so far) but if the motor sees knock, it will die. Maybe slowly, you may already be running fine with a few chipped pistons and don't even know it yet. You can't detect how much knock you have by ear, you have to have a scanner that scans Knock Retard. If you want to pulley down, do it the right way and at least scan.
08-09-2010
not true. i heard my first motor to knock, then it blew up. 3.5 pulley on an L36 with manifolds and a clogged cat. the best way i can describe the sound is like a rattle. it sounds like ball in a penut can actually.Originally Posted by matt5112
08-09-2010
But thats the rare case.
Most people have the engine run normally then its flashing CEL due to bent plug(s).
08-09-2010
I just checked - it's a 3.2. I've had it in the car for over a year with nothing but 85octane pump gas (and a lead foot).
At altitude, I get 20% less o2 than the rest of you. With operating o2 sensors, I should get 20% less gas than you too.
I've not run the CFM or stoichiometry calculations on it, but I always figured that a smaller pulley put me closer to stock at sea level.
I figure that the rotational speed of the pulley is close to linear to its output (this is not really the case as air is compressible, but it's close).
The rotation speed os RPM*pi*d. Since the first two variables are the same regardless of pulley size, I can also say that the speed is linear too. In short, a 3.2 pulley is less than 20% smaller than the stock 3.8 so its rotational speed would be less than 20% faster.
If the rotational speed is somewhat linearly representative to the CFM, then I'm getting back to sea level (or so).
The bottom line - I would like to scan it just to make sure.
One question along those lines: do you monitor KR real-time (my assumption) or is it stored in the ECM?
08-10-2010
I think it is more like Knock SJAndrew-tard.
You have a 3.2" pulley with no flow mods and crap octane...I bet if you pull out your plugs or when you took out your old ones...you'd fine missing electrodes or totally busted plugs from your lack of obvious caring and tight ass wallet...you can't be more jewish than I am about my car money wise and I use premium...are you really complaining about the extra $3 every fill up? If you are...just sell your boosted car now. Seriously. A 3.2" with the correct flow mods is headers/cam/intercooler territory...not bone stock. Even back in the day they tell you that you needed at least a cam and headers to run anything less.
"Should I care" about your ignorant equations and blunt fact of not listening to anyone on here that knows? I don't care. It's your car...why not put straight pipes on it and throw a 2.8" on there and watch the injectors run static and it'll explode the first time you WOT. Just please video tape it for our enjoyment...haven't seen fire works over a month.
Last edited by blueguy; 08-10-2010 at 12:18 AM.
| « Previous Thread | Next Thread » |
| Tags for this Thread |
| Bookmarks |
Bookmarks |
